aboutsummaryrefslogtreecommitdiffstats
diff options
context:
space:
mode:
authorVratko Polak <vrpolak@cisco.com>2020-11-19 15:14:34 +0100
committerVratko Polak <vrpolak@cisco.com>2020-11-19 17:18:03 +0100
commitcaf58700649f16bb636974562d6cafb008e87f09 (patch)
tree0c6ac26d54383f85a6800dbbeb1adefcae865405
parente6ade9f195dd104caf28892c903c5dd94f73f3cc (diff)
Methodology: Edit nat44 test spec doc
- Missing profile specifics and transaction counters. Change-Id: I6f7378e5fe9d639599c38545b0503354a8a65198 Signed-off-by: Vratko Polak <vrpolak@cisco.com>
-rw-r--r--docs/report/introduction/methodology_nat44.rst130
1 files changed, 97 insertions, 33 deletions
diff --git a/docs/report/introduction/methodology_nat44.rst b/docs/report/introduction/methodology_nat44.rst
index 5dc558f029..198837d17d 100644
--- a/docs/report/introduction/methodology_nat44.rst
+++ b/docs/report/introduction/methodology_nat44.rst
@@ -12,14 +12,17 @@ public range.
Following quantities are used to describe inside to outside IP address
and port bindings scenarios:
-- inside-addresses, ports-per-inside-address, number of inside source
- addresses (representing inside hosts) and number of TCP/UDP source
+- Inside-addresses, number of inside source addresses
+ (representing inside hosts).
+- Ports-per-inside-address, number of TCP/UDP source
ports per inside source address.
-- outside-addresses, number of outside (public) source addresses
- allocated to NAT44. The maximal number of ports-per-outside-address
- usable for NAT is 64 512 (in non-reserved port range 1024-65535,
- :rfc:`4787`).
-- sharing-ratio, equal to inside-addresses / outside-addresses.
+- Outside-addresses, number of outside (public) source addresses
+ allocated to NAT44.
+- Ports-per-outside-address, number of TCP/UDP source
+ ports per outside source address. The maximal number of
+ ports-per-outside-address usable for NAT is 64 512
+ (in non-reserved port range 1024-65535, :rfc:`4787`).
+- Sharing-ratio, equal to inside-addresses / outside-addresses.
CSIT NAT44 tests are designed to take into account the maximum number of
ports (sessions) required per inside host (inside-address) and at the
@@ -43,15 +46,7 @@ Initial CSIT NAT44 tests, including associated TG/TRex traffic profiles,
are based on ports-per-inside-address set to 63 and the sharing ratio of
1024. This approach is currently used for all NAT44 tests including
NAT44det (NAT44 deterministic used for Carrier Grade NAT applications)
-and NAT44ed.
-
-..
- .. TODO::
-
- Note that in the latter case, due to overloading of (ouside-address,
- outside-port) tuple for different endpoint destinations the actual
- sharing ratio is likely to different, as it will depend on the
- destination addresses used by NAT'ed flows.
+and NAT44ed (Endpoint Dependent).
Private address ranges to be used in tests:
@@ -70,13 +65,14 @@ NAT44 Session Scale
NAT44 session scale tested is govern by the following logic:
-- Number of inside addresses/hosts H[i] = (H[i-1] x 2^2) with H(0)=1 024, i = 1,2,3, ...
+- Number of inside-addresses(hosts) H[i] = (H[i-1] x 2^2) with H(0)=1 024,
+ i = 1,2,3, ...
- - H[i] = 1 024, 4 096, 16 384, 65 536, 262 144, 1 048 576, ...
+ - H[i] = 1 024, 4 096, 16 384, 65 536, 262 144, ...
-- Number of sessions S[i](ports-per-host) = H[i] * ports-per-inside-address
+- Number of sessions S[i] = H[i] * ports-per-inside-address
- - ports-per-host = 63
+ - ports-per-inside-address = 63
+---+---------+------------+
| i | hosts | sessions |
@@ -101,6 +97,11 @@ ip4, ip6 and l2, sending UDP packets in both directions
inside-to-outside and outside-to-inside. See
:ref:`data_plane_throughput` for more detail.
+The inside-to-outside traffic uses single destination address (20.0.0.0)
+and port (1024).
+The inside-to-outside traffic covers whole inside address and port range,
+the outside-to-inside traffic covers whole outside address and port range.
+
NAT44det translation entries are created during the ramp-up phase
preceding the throughput test, followed by verification that all entries
are present, before proceeding to the throughput test. This ensures
@@ -117,30 +118,55 @@ NAT44det scenario tested:
16515072.
- [mrr|ndrpdr|soak], MRR, NDRPDR or SOAK test.
+..
+ TODO: The -s{S} part is redundant,
+ we can save space by removing it.
+ TODO: Make traffic profile names resemble suite names more closely.
+
NAT44 Endpoint-Dependent
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
-NAT44ed is benchmarked using following methodologies:
-
-- Uni-directional throughput using *stateless* traffic profile.
+..
+ TODO: Is it possible to test a NAT44ed scenario where the outside source
+ address and port is limited to just one value?
+ In theory, as long as every inside source address&port traffic
+ uses a different destination address&port, there will be no conflicts,
+ and we could use bidirectional stateless profiles.
+ Possibly, VPP requires some amount of outside source address&port
+ to remain unused for security reasons. But we can try to see what happens.
+
+In order to excercise NAT44ed ability to translate based on both
+source and destination address and port, the inside-to-outside traffic
+varies also destination address and port. Destination port is the same
+as source port, destination address has the same offset as the source address,
+but applied to different subnet (starting with 20.0.0.0).
+
+As the mapping is not deterministic (for security reasons),
+we cannot easily use stateless bidirectional traffic profiles.
+Outside address and port range is fully covered,
+but we do not know which outside-to-inside source address and port to use
+to hit an open session of a particular outside address and port.
+
+Therefore, NAT44ed is benchmarked using following methodologies:
+
+- Unidirectional throughput using *stateless* traffic profile.
- Connections-per-second using *stateful* traffic profile.
-- Bi-directional throughput using *stateful* traffic profile.
+- Bidirectional PPS (see below) using *stateful* traffic profile.
-Uni-directional NAT44ed throughput tests are using TRex STL (Stateless)
+Unidirectional NAT44ed throughput tests are using TRex STL (Stateless)
APIs and traffic profiles, but with packets sent only in
-inside-to-outside direction. Due to indeterministic bindings of outside
-to inside (src_addr,src_port) that are created dynamically at flow start
-bidirectional testing is not possible with stateless traffic profiles.
-See :ref:`data_plane_throughput` for more detail.
-
-Similarly to NAT44det, NAT44ed uni-directional throughput tests include
+inside-to-outside direction.
+Similarly to NAT44det, NAT44ed unidirectional throughput tests include
a ramp-up phase to establish and verify the presence of required NAT44ed
-binding entries. NAT44ed CPS (connections-per-second) and throughput /
-PPS stateful tests do not have a ramp-up phase.
+binding entries.
Stateful NAT44ed tests are using TRex ASTF (Advanced Stateful) APIs and
traffic profiles, with packets sent in both directions. Tests are run
with both UDP and TCP/IP sessions.
+As both NAT44ed CPS (connections-per-second) and PPS (packets-per-second)
+stateful tests measure (also) session opening performance,
+they use state reset instead of ramp-up trial.
+That is also the reason why PPS tests are not called throughput tests.
Associated CSIT test cases use the following naming scheme to indicate
NAT44DET case tested:
@@ -164,3 +190,41 @@ NAT44DET case tested:
- [cps|pps], connections-per-second session establishment rate or
packets-per-second throughput rate.
- [mrr|ndrpdr], bidirectional stateful tests MRR, NDRPDR.
+
+Stateful traffic profiles
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+WiP.
+
+UDP CPS
+~~~~~~~
+
+TCP CPS
+~~~~~~~
+
+UDP PPS
+~~~~~~~
+
+TCP PPS
+~~~~~~~
+
+Ip4base tests
+^^^^^^^^^^^^^
+
+Contrary to stateless traffic profiles, we do not have a simple limit
+that would guarantee TRex is able to send traffic at specified load.
+For that reason, we have added tests where "nat44ed" is replaced by "ip4base".
+Instead of NAT44ed processing, the tests set minimalistic IPv4 routes,
+so that packets are forwarded in both inside-to-outside and outside-to-inside
+directions.
+
+The packets arrive to server end of TRex with different source address&port
+than in NAT44ed tests (no translation to outside values is done with ip4base),
+but those are not specified in the stateful traffic profiles.
+The server end uses the received address&port as destination
+for outside-to-inside traffic. Therefore the same stateful traffic profile
+works for both NAT44ed and ip4base test (of the same scale).
+
+The NAT44ed results are displayed together with corresponding ip4base results.
+If they are similar, TRex is probably the bottleneck.
+If NAT44ed result is visibly smaller, it describes the real VPP performance.